Michael Paycer — review of The Cultural Revolution by Frank Dikötter
Book Review · People's Trilogy (3 of 3)

The Cultural Revolution

Frank Dikötter · 2016 · A People's History, 1962–1976. The capstone of the trilogy — and its most surprising argument, that reform began from below.

The capstone runs from Mao's political recovery after the famine to the decade of chaos he set loose to crush his rivals and reassert his grip. Dikötter helpfully splits the period into phases: the Red Terror of 1966–68, when Red Guards hunted teachers and "class enemies" and each other; the militarized crackdown as the army restored order; and the often-overlooked "grey years" of the early-to-mid 1970s, when worn-out citizens quietly began dismantling the planned economy from below.

The freshest idea

That last phase is the book's real contribution. The black markets, private plots, and underground trade of the 1970s — people opting out of the system to survive — laid the groundwork for the reforms usually credited to Deng Xiaoping. Reform, in this telling, ratified what people had already started doing. It's the rare argument in the trilogy that points somewhere other than downward, and it reframes the reform era as something that welled up rather than being handed down.

Where it sits among the three

Of the three this is the most analytically ambitious but the least revelatory, since the Cultural Revolution is better-trodden ground than the famine or the early terror. The archival texture and the "grey years" thesis still make it more than a rehash — but if you're new to the subject, it lands harder after the first two books than on its own.

In the trilogy

This is the unraveling. After Mao's Great Famine, it shows the system consuming itself and, in its exhaustion, breeding the escape routes that became the reform era — the point where the trilogy's arc finally turns. Dikötter's later sequel, China After Mao (2022), picks the thread up from there.


References